Pizza Paul`s in Lakeville

What a horrible experience. I usually like Pizza Paul's. However, they have definitely lost any future service from me. I will always go to Vincenzos from now on. Food is better there anyways. I ordered from Pizza Paul's at 540pm for a quick meal deal for the family. Was told it would be 1 hour to 1 hour 15 mins for delivery. I called back after 1 hour and 25 minutes and was told he was on his way. Another 20 minutes goes by. I call again at 710 and hear more excuses. They offered to discount the order 50% and he will be there soon. Still waiting... 740 comes and goes, mind you that's 2 hours after placing the order. I called back to cancel the order. No thanks. What a joke. In no universe should a delivery of a pizza and wings take more than 2 hours!!! Never again.-Andrea Gambino

We come here every time we come to town. The last few times just haven't been the same. Very little breading on the breaded wings, pizza was soggy. I really hope they get this fixed cause we have always love to eat here.

Great steak subs

$19 for a large pizza! "Ok" pizza. I wish someone would open a Little Caesars around here so people could get decent pizza at a reasonable price.

The only reason I am giving this place two stars was because they use to be good. On there online menu they have a personal special, once I had already ordered it and was picking it up, they then told me they no longer offer that and charged me $18 for a burnt, thin and nasty crust pizza that was so tiny, with 6 soggy wings that barely had sauce on them. I brought to there attention that the gentlemen I spoke to on the phone did not tell me they no longer offered that special and for $18 dollars the food I received was horrible. I try to support small town business but they have lost mine. Won’t purchase from them again. Very disappointing.

Haven't been here in a while, but it was a great place to eat when we were younger

Called after waiting 1hr 40min for a delivery. Was told it was my fault should of called the other location. Just to let you know the other location is father away. You could not call and tell me maybe I should pick it up. Customer service sucks. Spent a lot of money here since moving to town. Major disappointment. Geovanis has better pizza. Thanks

Always enjoy Pizza Paul's, best pizza around

Nice little hometown pizza shop with a small eat in area. Awesome pizza with slices the size of your head! Fabulous turkey subs too! Great prices to boot.

$38 for a medium pizza & wings is absolutely ridiculous. And to charge an $8 delivery fee when we legit live 5 SECONDS down the road is ridiculous. And they were late with the food. I'll go elsewhere next time

I dont know why i keep ordering from here. I keep hoping it will go back to what it used to be bc i dont like other local option. I always pay more for extra cheese & there is barely any cheese on it!!!!

Had game on TV in KITCHEN, not in dining room. Workers more concerned with game than taking care of customers. Mixed up my order with someone else's. I can understand mixing the orders, but why have a tv in the dining room if it's never on?

Best pizza in Lakeville. The new team there are really good at making great food.

Really good, just wish the pizza and wings were more consistant!

Great chicken wings. Ok pizza.

Calzone good, too much extra bread and a little burnt, but tasty

Don't think I went there. Perhaps a take out slice.

I love Pizza Paul's pizza, subs, brownies and balls. Friendly service and the place got a makeover so it looks great.

My family and I have been customers at Pizza Paul's for literally decades, but because of consistently horrible customer service and attitude from the employees and managers when the order is messed up (which at this point it has been wrong 4 out of the last 5 times we've ordered, even after clarifying the order before hanging up), we - as of today - decided to no longer support their restaurant. They don't seem to care at all about their customers or righting their own mistakes, which is just bad business. I do not recommend them at all.

Great local pizza shop. Friendly staff and good food. Try their boneless wings.

Finally had some last night after a friend recommended them. Great pizza. Nice thin and airy crust. They don't skimp on the cheese. Close to NYC Style.

Boneless wings were just amazing along with pizza

Big slices normally pepperoni and cheese and what every specialty they feel like making at the time this place is nice if your looking for a quick bite to eat service is good very friendly people and verry reasonably priced. Paul's wings arw really good to and they always cook to order

Pizza is doughy and edges are burned....fried dough is burn 2 a crisp...and had 2 wait half hr over of wat they said it would be...I would rather burn the money than give it 2 these guys!!

Excellent Friendly Service Tasty Tuna Fish Sub

I love their pizza, subs and balls. Friendly workers.

Nice remodel inside. Pizza is awesome and you'll never see the same person working twice

Good pie and wings, friendly staff as well

Good wings. Great owner. Good pizza

Delivery guy has attitude and these manager has attitude food came cold when order hot sub

Waited 25 minutes for a cheese steak and cauliflower. Then they still got order wrong. On a Monday and not busy at all. I work in the food industry and that's horrible service. Place had dirty tables

Worst! Live locally and want to support but just bought a sheet pizza. It was burned, and most the slices had huge burned air bubbles on them. When we called they told us we had to drive back and bring the pizza if we wanted a new sheet. They literally could care less. Will be going else where from now on.

Paul is a good guy who doesn't afraid of anything. Good pizza.

Good service, fair prices, hot food

How can you be out of green peppers and mozzarella sticks! Who does your ordering? The pizzas always soggy. No more chances Mr Paul!!! Your food is not edible for humans, but my dog will suffer! Only because he knows no better horrible food horrible service also you shouldn't have to re cook your pizza asta la Vista soggy

I have been going here for years. Never paid $18.00 for a small pizza with pep and extra cheese before. Also bought a calzone with it. My order was $34.00. not including the tip $37.00. and 4 bucks for delivery. The girl taking the order said that the amount was correct. I have NEVER paid that much. Won't do it again. Thanks.

We ordered the “Large Special “ tonight. The bill came to $50.10 including tip. Ordered a large white pizza with artichokes, spinach and tomato. A white pizza consists of aioli or garlic , oil and Parmesan. We also ordered 12 Buffalo hot wings and 12 country sweet wings. Our pizza had tomato sauce, a few spinach leaves, almost nonexistent artichokes and a few tomatoes. It was cold and took 1.5 hour to get here ( in their defense, they said up to 1.5 hrs on phone). It was totally flavorless without seasoning or spice and IT WAS NOT A WHITE PIZZA!The wings were ok. All in all disappointing for the price and the wait. Probably won’t go back. Have been customers for around 6 years. Plan to order pizza in Rochester and bring it home or make our own! Lakeville pizza not great.

Great place! Subs are great!

Pizza was super gooey, mushrooms tasted awful. Only good thing was the wings and the hot delivery guy. I will not be ordering from them again

My family always orders from Pizza Paul's and have never been disappointed. They love the pizza, wings, and subs. There all time favorite is the sub-zone. If you have never tried one you don't know what your missing.

Some of my favorite wings, great pizza too.

One of the best chicken and cranberry salads I have had in a really long time. Thank you.

Always forgetting some of my order, Geneseo pizza Paul's is way better

Love their pizza!

The best meatball subs in the Rochester region.

Nice place. It’s clean, and the pizza was good.

Pizza was good but we had to wait an hour

Great pizza. Friendly service.

Love it! Great wings, delicious pizza with its own unique taste/seasoning

Ya it’s good food and I’m usually very critical. Some people get to stingy with these reviews